The Heart of Nonprofit Success: Donor Retention
Photo: Canva
As someone deeply connected to the nonprofit sector, I’ve learned that the heart of our success lies in how we treat our supporters. Yet, one crucial lesson stands out: donor retention is far more vital than simply attracting new supporters. While attracting donors is important, nurturing the relationships we already have is where true impact lies. As many of us who are front-line fundraisers have heard at some point in our careers, acquiring a new donor requires more resources than stewarding and retaining an existing one.
According to the Fundraising Effectiveness Project, the current national donor retention rate hovers around 45%. While this figure highlights the importance of investing in our existing relationships, it’s important to remember that even a small effort can make significant strides in improving retention rates and build lasting connections with donors.
To enhance donor retention, consistent communication is essential. Regular updates about our progress and “tug at the heart” success stories keep donors connected to our missions. Additionally, cultivating relationships through personal touches—like phone calls and handwritten notes—can deepen their commitment. Hosting donor appreciation events can further strengthen the bonds, transforming casual supporters into passionate champions for our causes.
Calculating donor retention is straightforward: take the number of donors from the previous year, divide it by the number of donors at the end of the year, and multiply by 100 to get the percentage. This metric helps you track our progress and identify areas for improvement.
To support these efforts, utilizing our donor database or CRM system is invaluable. This tool allows us to organize donor information, track interactions, and analyze giving patterns, enabling personalized communication and targeted outreach. This tool can significantly enhance our ability to steward relationships and ultimately improve our retention rates.
Building a community that drives lasting change within our organizations and the lives we impact is essential. By prioritizing donor retention and leveraging tools, we can turn one-time givers into lifelong supporters, sustaining our efforts through meaningful connections.
A fundraising consultant at M. Gale, Christina Moore-Salinas, CFRE, enjoys sharing a common goal with clients. “It’s inspiring to see the dedication and passion that nonprofit teams have for their cause. To be a part of that effort is truly fulfilling. I enjoy getting to know an organization’s mission and values and see firsthand the impact they have on the community.”
Outside of work, Christina is passionate about all things theater – ballet, opera, symphony, concerts, and musicals! Ask her about which Broadway performance she’s seen 42 times.
